Winter Pizza Inspiration (recipe: Caramelized Onions) (2024)

Vine-ripened tomatoes and fresh basil are my absolute favorite pizza toppings. I slice the tomatoes thinly, tear the basil and marry them under a blanket of fresh mozzarella. A drizzle of olive oil and…heaven.

However, this deluxe pizza margherita is a summer-only treat, as local fresh tomatoes are but a memory of last August and – aww snap! – my basil plant got hit with frost months ago. Now, tomatoes are tasteless rocks, a single bell pepper costs upwards of $3, and zucchinis are shriveled and soft. Not at all ideal garnish for my Friday night pizza.

So what is one to do during the winter months when the pizza cravings hit? I don’t love loading up pizza with meat – I prefer my ham glazed with a side of scalloped potatoes, thank you very much – and gravitate toward vegetarian toppings, no matter the season. Here are some of my favorites, plus my secret weapon recipe to great tasting pizza anytime.

Winter Pizza Toppings

Yes, homemade pizza is synonymous with summer, with its luscious tomatoes and colorful peppers, but winter pizzas can be just as scrumptious as their summer counterparts – and even more creative.

Pictured at top of the post: Kale, Artichoke, Mushroom and Sundried Tomato Pizza.

Consider an assortment of these toppings for your next pizza party:

Canned and Pickled Produce

• Olives; black and green
• Canned artichokes
• Sundried tomatoes; sliced or pesto
• Pesto. I still have frozen pesto from my summer batch cooking efforts. Yep, I’m pretty happy about that. Almost as good as fresh torn basil on my pizza.

Produce

• Kale and other winter greens
• Onion, Garlic, & Leeks. Sliced or diced, raw or sautéed, do not underestimate what onions and their relatives can add to pizza.
• Fruits. Green apple & cheddar cheese work in a panini, so why not on a pizza? Figs and pineapple are also excellent choices, though not quite ‘local’ fare for most of us.
• Squash. I might have a hard time getting them past my children, but for more educated palates, small cubes of par-boiled butternut squash or roasted acorn squash are fantastic on pizza. (see recipe below)
• Mushrooms. Sure we usually slice up the common cultivated white mushroom, but there’s no need to stop there; almost any sort of mushrooms work for pizza.

Meat & Seafood

My sister-in-law, Laura, makes a killer ‘white pizza’ that I try to reproduce every once in a while. There’s something about it that is so satisfying, like a bowl of creamy Penne Alfredo, but in pizza form. It must have shrimp, and roasted garlic is a sure way to gain fans fast. My version (pictured above) contains a soft, crumbly cheese (I use Boursin Garlic Herbs), sliced button mushrooms, small shrimp, mozzarella cheese and thinly sliced red onion.

Shrimp on pizza? Yes, please.

While I’m satisfied with vegetables and mushrooms, Danny appreciates something more substantial in his pizza. Grilled chicken, seafood, bacon, sausage, and cured Italian meats are all favorites.

Crust, Cheese & Sauce: the other important elements of great pizza

Crust

When we were dating, Danny used to call pizza crust “the handles” and left the gnawed edges conspicuously on the side of his plate, only to toss them later. I objected. I made him dough from scratch. These recipes won him over.

• Whole-Wheat Pizza Dough
• Honey Pizza Dough

Cheese

Don’t limit cheese to just mozzarella. Try crumbled feta, provolone, or something with a bit more bite like blue or asiago.

Sauce

Remember back in July when we talked about canning homemade pizza sauce? Boy, am I ever glad we covered that topic. My jars of Roasted Tomato and Garlic Pizza Sauce have been gracing our pizzas all year long.

Of course, a simple can of tomato paste also works. If that is all you have on hand, then spread it very thin and add a drizzle of olive oil over the bottom of the pizza.

Link Love: Winter Pizzas that Sing

• Roasted Butternut Squash & Caramelized Onion Pizza with Gorgonzola :: Closet Cooking
• Pizza with Kale, Roasted Garlic & Four Cheeses :: Eggs on Sunday
• Ultra-Thin-Crust Pizza with Onions, Mushrooms, and Ricotta :: Simply Recipes
• Sundried Tomato Pizza :: Cheeky Kitchen
• Artichoke, Mushroom and Goat Cheese Pizza :: How to Simplify

Let’s hear it; what do you top your pizza with in February?